THE ROLE OF GOVERNMENT
Some people complain that government regulation of the economy is too little,
too late. Others scoff that the U.S. economy is no free market at all, with so
much regulation. Some of the most enduring debates of U.S. economic history
focus on the role of government.
Emphasis on private ownership jibes with U.S. beliefs about personal freedom.
Since independence, Americans have most often sought to limit government's
authority over individuals, including its role in the economic realm. And most
Americans have believed that private ownership of business is more likely than
government ownership to achieve the best economic outcomes.
Even so, most Americans want governments to perform certain tasks in the
economy, and the U.S. legal system provides a sound infrastructure on which to
do business.
Businesses—at least legitimate businesses—need permission from governments to
operate at all. Corporations need a charter from one of the 50 state
governments. (More than half of U.S. publicly traded corporations are
incorporated in the tiny state of Delaware because they like its regulatory
regime.) Businesses need various registrations, licenses, and permits from local
governments.
Businesses need the court system for protecting property rights, enforcing
contracts, and resolving commercial disputes.
Governments protect consumers from business. The federal government, for
example, uses antitrust laws to control or break up monopolistic business
combinations that become powerful enough to escape competition. Governments
redress consumers' grievances about business fraud and enforce recalls of
dangerous products.
Governments regulate private companies' activities to protect public health
and safety or maintain a healthy environment. The U.S. Food and Drug
Administration bans harmful drugs, for example, and the Occupational Safety and
Health Administration protects workers from hazards on the job.
Since Americans have become increasingly concerned about the environmental
impact of industry, Congress has passed many laws to control air, water, and
ground pollution. Establishment of the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
(EPA) in 1970 brought together many federal programs charged with protecting the
environment. The EPA sets and enforces limits on pollution and establishes
timetables to bring polluters into line with standards.
Government involvement in the economy increased significantly during the most
serious economic downturn in U.S. history, the Great Depression (1929-1940).
President Franklin D. Roosevelt launched what he called the New Deal to rescue
the economy.
Many of the laws and institutions that define the modern U.S. economy emerged
from New Deal legislation extending federal authority in regulating business and
providing public welfare. The New Deal established minimum standards for wages
and hours on the job. It created programs and agencies now deemed indispensable,
including the Securities and Exchange Commission, which regulates the stock
market; the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, which guarantees bank
deposits; and the Social Security system, which provides retirees' pensions
based on contributions they made while in the workforce.
Even with all its regulations, the United States in 2007 was ranked No. 3 by
the World Bank in ease of doing business, after Singapore and New Zealand. All
10 ranking categories pertain in some way to government policy: starting a
business, dealing with licenses, employing workers, registering property,
getting credit, protecting investors, paying taxes, trading across borders,
enforcing contracts, closing a business.
Government policies can also promote businesses. For example, tax breaks not
only promote the public goal of home ownership—nearly 70 percent of U.S.
households own their own home—but also expand business opportunities for real
estate, construction, and mortgage finance companies.
Governments conduct research and development. Federal government research
spending goes mostly to developing and testing weapons systems, but also helps
keep the United States as the center of biological science research, for
example.
Governments aim to advance U.S. business goals in international trade. State
governments promote exports of their industries. The federal government aims to
negotiate lower tariffs and other foreign barriers to U.S. imports and to
protect U.S. companies from unfair foreign competition.
Governments provide certain services—such as national defense, administration
of justice, education, environmental protection, road construction, space
exploration—for which they are viewed as better suited than private businesses.
Governments take care of needs beyond the reach of market forces. They
provide insurance payments to people who lose their jobs and low-cost loans to
people who lose their homes in natural disasters. The Social Security system,
financed by a tax on employers and employees, accounts for the largest portion
of Americans' retirement income. The Medicare program pays for some medical
costs of the elderly; the Medicaid program, for medical costs of low-income
families. In many states, government maintains institutions for the mentally ill
or people with severe disabilities. The federal government provides food stamps
for poor families to purchase food. The federal and state governments jointly
provide grants to support low-income parents with children.
What about government's role steering the economy?
|